The Battle of the Labyrinth (Percy Jackson and the Olympians), Rick Riordan, 2008, Book Review

battle-of-the-labyrinthThis fourth book in Riordan’s Percy Jackson & the Olympians series is vastly entertaining, as always. Within, Percy and his friends must enter the huge labyrinth that is under the surface of the earth, just beneath the mortal world. Grover goes in search of Pan, whom he is convinced is hiding out, to substantiate his claim to the Council of the Cloven Elders, who want to revoke his searcher’s license.  Percy and Annabeth must stop Luke, who’s seeking to use the labyrinth to lead the army of Kronos into Camp Halfblood and destroy it.

Riordan uses his boundless imagination to bring us a giant hellhound named Mrs. O’Leary, a Dodo bird that hums “It’s a Small World,” fire-breathing horses (“I wonder if it hurts their sinuses”), a dragon lady who guards Alcatraz, and a great deal of suspense and excitement. He also has a wealth of great quotes, thanks to his super sense of understatement, a few of which I’ll share here:

“The last thing I wanted to do on my summer break was blow up another school.” (Another trademark Riordan opening line.)

“We’d spent maybe ten minutes together, during which time I’d accidentally swung my sword at her, she’d saved my life, and I’d run away chased by a band of supernatural killing machines. You know, your typical chance meeting.”

“I tried to fall asleep, but I couldn’t. Something about getting chased by a large dragon lady with poison swords made it real hard to relax.”

“‘So,’ my mom said when I was done with my story, ‘you wrecked Alcatraz Island, made Mount St. Helens explode, and displaced half a million people, but at least you’re safe.’ That’s my mom, always looking on the bright side.”

There are a few details I don’t care for in the series, like how the gods follow western civilization, moving Olympus from Greece to New York City. Other places move to America, as well, like the door to the Underworld and the stronghold of Kronos. I see why he does it, to create an American setting for his American readers and his American character, but it just seems wierd. The Labyrinth also moves and shifts and changes, so tunnels or rooms are never in the same location twice (except for Pan, who, incidentally, is still under the same state Grover found him in last year). And, of course, I’ve never really been keen on the whole premise of promiscuous, dysfunctional gods, but as it’s been pretty much in the background, I wouldn’t bar the series from my kids.

But in The Battle of the Labyrinth, an intensification of some darker themes will probably put this series in the 12+ age category for my kids, along with the likes of Harry Potter. In this one, Kronos, who is the epitome of evil and who is seeking to destroy Olympia and western civilization, takes over Luke’s (a kid) body with Luke’s permission. This doesn’t settle too well with me. Yes, Luke is a bad guy, and I haven’t read the last book yet (which I suspect redeems Luke). In the meantime, I don’t think I want my kids reading this series until they gain a little more wisdom and maturity.

5 thoughts on “The Battle of the Labyrinth (Percy Jackson and the Olympians), Rick Riordan, 2008, Book Review

  1. as you know I LOVE THIS BOOK!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! 😉 I liked the adventure in it. I didn’t mind how things were moving around because it’s not supposed to be how it really is. My mom says she thinks the difference (for her) between the Percy Jackson series and others (Harry Potter) is how much humor is mixed in (a lot of the Percy Jackson stuff isn’t too serious). I see your points about the whole Luke thing, that was creepy for me. It’s cool to see what different people think about what we all read! 🙂 🙂 😉
    Erik

  2. AH! Now I see why Erik was asking me why Percy Jackson is OK for him to read LOL! As he stated, I think it’s the humor that sets it apart. I think is makes it a “not so serious” story. The dysfunctional god thing makes me cringe, but my kiddo doesn’t “get it” on that level. I also agree with the Luke possession (that was one section, among others in the series, we read together and talked about). This is a great balanced review!

  3. Ginny, I think you did hit on something there – the humor does lighten this series considerably. Riordan is hilarious! But it’s a tougher one to call. Good for you for reading with Erik. There were parts of Harry Potter that I discussed with my daughter, too, after we both finished reading it separately, even at age 12. She hasn’t been too interested in this series, so I haven’t pushed her toward it yet.

    Thanks, Timothy!

    Erik, I’m not sure I understood. Did you mention liking this one? 😉

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s